Saturday, June 4, 2016

Open Source based Hyper-Converged Infrastructures and Hadoop

According to a report from Simplivity [1] Hyper-Converged Infrastructures are used by more than 50% of the interviewed businesses, tendentious increasing. But what does this mean for BigData solutions, and Hadoop especially? What tools and technologies can be used, what are the limitations and the gains from such a solution?

To build a production ready and reliable private cloud to support Hadoop clusters as well as on-demand and static I have made great experience with OpenStack, Saltstack and the Sahara plugin for Openstack.
Openstack supports Hadoop-on-demand per Sahara, it's also convenient to use VM's and install a Hadoop Distribution within, especially for static clusters with special setups. The Openstack project provides ready to go images per [2], as example for Vanilla 2.7.1 based Hadoop installations. As an additional benefit, Openstack supports Docker [3], which adds an additional layer of flexibility for additional services, like Kafka [4] or SolR [5].

Costs and Investment
The costs of such an Infrastructure can vary, depending on the hardware and future strategy. Separate compute and storage nodes have been proven in the past, and should be used in future, too. The benefits outweigh the limitations, mostly end up in having move bare metal servers than in a high packed (compute and storage in one server) environment. Additionally, a more stretched environment
helps to balance peaks and high usage better than packed servers. A typical setup would have 2 controller nodes (for HA reasons), a decent count on compute nodes (high memory and CPU count) and several storage nodes (1 CPU, 8 or 16GB RAM and plenty JBOD (just a bunch of disks)). Those storage nodes should have 2 LVM’s (or raids, if that feels better) to avoid later conflicts with production and development / staging / QA buildouts.

Technology
Hadoop itself has some limitations, especially in Hyper-Converged Infrastructures, given by the demand on data locality for batch processes (MapReduce). In a typical cloud environment, like Sahara is providing in Openstack, the storage area is virtualized, and all data is transferred over the network stack. This can be avoided by using VM images for a persistent Hadoop cluster, as a production one mostly is. The data storage (HDFS) will then be provided within the VM and can be extended by mounting additional volumes to the VM (partitions for the data nodes, for example). In both implementations, Cloud based by Sahara and VM, the use of HDFS caching [6] is recommended. This will dramatically speed up the platform for analytical workloads by using columnar based storage formats like Parquet or Kudu [7], together with Hive on Spark [8]. To identify bottlenecks analyzer like Dr. Elephant [9] are very useful and recommended.

Hadoop on demand provides much more flexibility as a static cluster has, especially in terms of load peaks, dynamical resource allocation and cost efficiency. But there are some points to consider. The first and most important one is the separation of block storage and computing. Hadoop itself works with different other distributed filesystems, like ceph [10], but those often rely on Hadoop 1 (MRv1) and Yarn and MRv2 aren’t supported (yet).
The best solution here is to use the standard HDFS layer over cinder [11], which provides good performance with reliability and decent IOpS. The second, and also important one is the network layer. Every compute and storage node should have at least bonded 1GB uplinks, 10G are better (but more expensive). The network needs to be separated into front- and backend. The front-end link provides accessibility to the services the cluster provides to its users, and the back-end provides inter-cluster-communication only. As a third point the use of in-memory filesystems like Alluxio [12] (former Tachyon) may be considered, especially for research clusters, like Genome calculation or NRT applications with high ingestion rates of small data points, like IoT devices typically do.
With these points in mind, streaming based applications getting the most out of this approach, given by the high flexibility and the availability to deal with large load peaks by adding computing resources dynamically. 

Conclusion
Using Hyper-Converged Infrastructures in the world of BigData tools is trending now and proves the success of the private cloud idea. Large companies like LinkedIN, Google, Facebook are on this road since years, and the success outweighs the implementation and maintenance considerations.

List of tools used in this article
Openstack:
Sahara:

Saltstack - Openstack:

Links and References: